Posted on: 28 November 2012

Essay:
The Aryan Invasion Theory and Hindu Politics
By David Frawley

That the Aryan invasion theory itself has been persistently used to promote anti-Hindu political agendas is similarly ignored. The invasion theory has been used like a stick to beat Hindus for the last two hundred years (some of these same scholars who are rasing the political bogey about the rejection of the theory have used it to attack Hinduism themselves). That Hindus might use the demise of the theory fortheir own benefit is only to be expected and is perhaps little more than getting even or restoring balance on these issues.

The British used the theory to discredit any indigenous civilization in the subcontinent, which was seen as succumbing to various waves of invaders from the West, making for a patchwork culture derived from outside influences. This made the British rule seem just another and perhaps necessary phase of a long invasionist saga.

The communists used the Aryan Invasion theory as the basis for their history of India, substituting the caste war of the Brahmin invaders from Central Asia for the European class war model. Dravidian nationalists used it to their advantage, claiming an older purer Dravidian culture that was different from that of the Aryan invaders fromthe north. The Dalits used it to identify themselves with the original inhabitants of the country enslaved by the invading Brahmin dominated Aryans. Christian and Islamic groups have used it to brand the Hindu Rishis as primitive poets leading nomadic hordes, making the Vedas, the scriptures of Hinduism, as withoutany real spirituality! In fact, there is probably no other theory of ancient history that has been used with such blatant political intent or missionary aggression. The theory has even been used by some scholars to make the Yoga tradition or such systems as Tantra, Shaivism, Samkhya, Buddhism and Jainism non-Aryan (though, for example, original Buddhism calls itself 'AryaDharma').

Given this scenario any group would use the demise of such a hostile theory to reclaim value for their own traditions. But to use any possible advantage that Hindus may derive from this historical revindication as a grounds to reject it is ridiculous.

Read more:

http://bit.ly/Y5Y0bp


 View Post on Facebook

Comments from Facebook

as an Indian and as a Muslim I really don't understand this whole Aryan invader thing...

Shakuntala Iyer something of your interest

Vazzxo Xozam: This article highlights the politics and explores the hidden persuasions behind this theroy.

When diplomacy and politics enters academia, history suffers.

Acharya Vamadeva Shastri is most learned in Vedic Shastra including Jyotish shastra

What we fail to understand is that shame or honour are with the people who dod those deeds. Each one's karma with himself. Why must we condemn their later.generations or praise their later generations when these generations had no role in those acts or deeds.

ok thanks... i will check it out..

Not only we should not judge the later generations which had no part in those deeds, but we cannot judge the deeds either since their ethics were different than ours. The true historian remains objective.

Vazzxo, I suspect there never were any "Aryans"...it seems to me that prehistoric people would more likely move inland from the tropical seashore- as living inland requires more effort, and possibly special skills- and then go further north.

The various ways in which the theory has been used politically offers an amazing perspective on historical manipulation in the Indian sub continent. A trenchant and straightforward description!

With reference to amin Hamza's comment: agree with u. Why should the current generations take any credit or blame for whatever was done? That makes the whole concept of caste based reservation a big conspiracy. If only India becomes reservation free, can't imagine.

David Frawley -Acharya Bamdeva is the most learned vedic scholar

Time is the main factor on which probably humans will never have control on....invasion or not it will left for the future genration historians to understand and this will cary on..infinitely..

people and countries say whatever they like. none can deny the truth about Bharat is "Dev Bhumi" (land where Gods reside".

Truth is what it is. Bharat is the only nation, where people from all over the World, go to seek spiritualism, WHY ?

"Satyameva Jayate - Na-anrutam" Let Truth-alone Triumph and Not Dishonesty and Untruth.